Explore · Tax policy
Which policies have decreased federal capital gains taxes since 1945?
Capital gains already received preferential treatment in 1945. This topic compares selected later federal laws, including the 1978 and 1981 cuts discussed in the linked interview, using official law and congressional tax analysis.
“Decreased” identifies a verified reduction for the stated taxpayer or asset category. “Did not decrease” includes rate increases and extensions that kept the immediately preceding rate. Each position states the before-and-after rates and relevant dates.
Initial coverage follows major rate changes and extensions from 1978 through 2017. Individual and corporate rates are identified separately. This is not a complete inventory of exemptions, deferrals, small-business provisions or every law enacted since 1945.
An archived copy of YouTube’s displayed transcript provides the interview passages and timestamp markers. Caption wording has not been independently checked against the audio. The separate podcast edition has different timing. Official laws establish the legal findings.
Positions (11)
- Revenue Act of 1978 supports: Before the law, the 50% deduction left half of net long-term gains subject to a top ordinary rate of 70%, for a regular-tax maximum of 35%. Section 402 increased the deduction to 60%, leaving 40% taxable and reducing that regular maximum to 28% for gains after 10/31/1978. Separate minimum-tax and maximum-tax interactions could make the earlier marginal burden higher than 35%. This comparison excludes those interactions. The law was signed by President Jimmy Carter on 11/06/1978; it was enacted before Ronald Reagan’s presidency.
- Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981 supports: The regular maximum on individual long-term capital gains fell from 28% to 20%. Section 102 provided a 20% limit for qualified gains after 06/09/1981 during the transition year. Starting in 1982, the reduction of the top ordinary rate from 70% to 50%, combined with the existing 60% capital gains deduction, produced the same 20% maximum: 40% × 50%. Commonly called Kemp–Roth, the law was signed by President Ronald Reagan on 08/13/1981.
- Tax Reform Act of 1986 opposes: The act repealed the individual deduction for net long-term capital gains for taxable years beginning after 12/31/1986. The maximum rose from 20% in 1986 to 28% in 1987. Some taxpayers later faced a higher effective marginal rate from bracket phaseouts, so 28% describes the headline statutory treatment. Cuts to ordinary income rates in this law did not constitute a capital gains rate cut.
- Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 supports: Section 311 lowered the general individual maximum from 28% to 20%, and reduced the rate for qualifying gains in the lowest ordinary bracket from 15% to 10%. Relief generally applied to gains after 05/06/1997. For sales after 07/28/1997, the new 10% and 20% rates generally required a holding period over 18 months. Collectibles, depreciation-related gains and other special categories retained separate rules. The law also provided later 8% and 18% rates for qualifying five-year gains. The following 1998 law shortened the 18-month requirement.
- Internal Revenue Service Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998 supports: The general long-term maximum stayed at 20%. For ordinary investment property held more than 12 months but no more than 18 months, however, section 5001 extended the lower rates retroactively to gains taken into account after 12/31/1997. The maximum for this previously mid-term category fell from 28% to 20%; the qualifying lower-bracket rate fell from 15% to 10%. This was an eligibility expansion, not a further cut to the 20% maximum already available for longer-held property.
- Jobs and Growth Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2003 supports: For qualifying individual long-term gains on or after 05/06/2003, the general maximum fell from 20% to 15%. The ordinary lower-bracket capital gains rate fell from 10% to 5%, with a 0% rate scheduled for 2008. Special five-year rates and holding requirements were also repealed. Collectibles, certain real-estate gains and other special categories remained subject to their own rules. The original reductions were temporary; later laws extended them.
- Tax Increase Prevention and Reconciliation Act of 2005 opposes: Although its title says 2005, this law was enacted on 05/17/2006. Section 102 extended the 2003 capital gains provisions from the end of 2008 through the end of 2010. The general maximum was 15% before enactment and remained 15% afterward. The already scheduled 0% lower-bracket rate for 2008 continued through 2010. Relative to the rates in force immediately before enactment, this was an extension rather than a new rate cut. It prevented the scheduled expiration from raising rates.
- Tax Relief, Unemployment Insurance Reauthorization, and Job Creation Act of 2010 opposes: Section 102 moved the sunset of the 2003 capital gains provisions from 12/31/2010 to 12/31/2012. The general individual maximum remained 15%, and the qualifying lower-bracket rate remained 0%. This law prevented a scheduled increase. Under this topic’s comparison with the immediately preceding rates, it did not introduce a further decrease. It is distinct from the separate 2010 health reconciliation law that created the investment-income surtax.
- Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010 opposes: The new net investment income tax rose from 0% to 3.8% for affected high-income individuals, effective for taxable years beginning after 12/31/2012. It applies to the lesser of net investment income or modified adjusted gross income above the statutory threshold, including $200,000 for single filers and $250,000 for joint filers. Its definition can include capital gains but has exclusions. It did not itself raise the ordinary long-term rate from 15% to 20%; that was the 2012 tax relief law. When both apply, the 20% top rate plus this 3.8% tax yields 23.8%.
- American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012 opposes: Signed on 01/02/2013, the act applies these changes to taxable years beginning after 12/31/2012. It made the lower 0% and 15% rates permanent while introducing a 20% rate for gains in the highest bracket. The top regular maximum therefore rose from 15% to 20%. The separate 3.8% net investment income tax, enacted in 2010, also began in 2013 and can bring the combined rate to 23.8%. Permanently extending lower brackets did not lower the immediately preceding 15% general maximum.
- 2017 tax law (commonly called the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act) supports: For taxable years beginning after 12/31/2017, section 13001 replaced the graduated corporate rates, whose top rate was 35%, with a flat 21% rate on corporate taxable income. Corporations’ net capital gains are included in that income, so the top corporate capital gains rate fell from 35% to 21%. This decrease concerns corporations. The standard individual long-term capital gains rates remained 0%, 15% and 20%, and the separate 3.8% investment-income tax remained. Other provisions changed brackets, deductions and particular investment incentives.
Sources
- Capital Gains Taxes: An Overview, Congressional Research Service
- How WWII Doomed “Creativity” and Led to Its Takeover by Silicon Valley and Weapons Companies, Tucker Carlson Network
- How WWII Doomed “Creativity” and Led to Its Takeover by Silicon Valley and Weapons Companies, Tucker Carlson Network